The paper · methods, results, references
A result you can check, not just a number you receive
Finite-element analysis · sequence analysis · verification against published references
Abstract
A simulation can be numerically clean and physically plausible while the model behind it is wrong. Sojist runs the computation on managed cloud compute and returns, with every result, the evidence needed to judge it: a comparison against closed-form theory where one exists, against published reference data where it does not, and a record that lets the run be repeated exactly.
- verification
- finite elements
- sequence alignment
- reproducibility
- ASME V&V 40
1Introduction
Existing tools solve the physics. None of them state how much the answer should be believed. On a validated cantilever, the computed tip deflection agreed with the Euler–Bernoulli solution [1] to 0.086 %, while the peak stress exceeded beam theory by 29.5 % — correctly, because the formula has no term for the concentration at the clamp.
A naive equality check would have rejected that correct solution. The inverse is worse: a wrong boundary condition, material or load surface can produce a smooth, converged result that passes every numerical test. The engineer who built the model is usually the one who signs it off.
Regulators now accept simulation as evidence. The FDA recognises ASME V&V 40 [2] for establishing the credibility of a computational model — and its own review literature notes that the standard supplies no mechanism for deciding when a result is acceptable.
Request access →| Quantity | Reference | Measured | Δ | Mode | Copy row |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tip deflection | 9.1429 mm | 9.1350 mm | −0.086 % | direct | |
| Peak stress | 48.00 MPa | 62.14 MPa | +29.5 % | lower bound | |
| Longest ORF | 1132 aa | 1132 aa | 0 | direct | |
| Reads mapped | — | 99.76 % | — | reported |
— no reference value exists; the quantity is reported, not judged.
2Method
Every run follows the same five steps, and each step reports its own telemetry event.
- 2.1
Specification
Geometry, material, constraints and loads are declared explicitly. The system does not infer what was modelled; the declaration is the claim being tested.
- 2.2
Provisioning
A dedicated compute instance is launched for each run, installs its solver toolchain, and terminates itself when the run ends. Nothing is left running between runs.
- 2.3
Solution
Established solvers do the numerical work: CalculiX [3] with gmsh [4] for structures, minimap2 [5] for sequence alignment. Sojist does not reimplement them.
- 2.4
Verification
Each quantity is compared in the mode it permits. Direct: equal to theory within tolerance. Lower bound: at least the theoretical value, used for peak stress at a constraint. An unmeasured quantity joins no verdict, and a run with nothing measured is inconclusive — never passed.
- 2.5
Record
Specification, per-stage telemetry, solver output and verdict are kept together, so a run can be inspected afterwards and repeated. A retried run reproduced its original metrics exactly.
Step 2.4 is where tools usually stop short. Fig. 3 lists every closed-form case the platform checks against; Fig. 4 shows how a single quantity is judged; Box 1 lets you run the check yourself.
aCantilever, end load
δ = PL³ / 3EI
Roark, Table 8.1, case 1a
δ direct · σ lower bound
bCantilever, uniform load
δ = qL⁴ / 8EI
Roark, Table 8.1, case 1c
δ direct · σ lower bound
cSimply supported, central load
δ = PL³ / 48EI
Roark, Table 8.1, case 2a
δ direct · σ lower bound
dSimply supported, uniform load
δ = 5qL⁴ / 384EI
Roark, Table 8.1, case 2c
δ direct · σ lower bound
eBar in tension
δ = PL / AE, σ = P / A
Hooke’s law, uniform bar
δ direct · σ direct
aDirect
Accepted when |Δ| ≤ t. Used for deflection.
bLower bound
Accepted when measured ≥ reference × (1 − t). Used for peak stress at a support, which a 3-D model can only raise above beam theory. A direct check would have accepted +29.5 % only with t above 29.5 %.
cNothing measured
No value, so no comparison and no verdict: the run is inconclusive — never passed.
3Results
Each capability below was run and checked against an external reference.
3.1Structural benchmark
For a cantilever with an end load, beam theory gives the tip deflection and the nominal stress at the root as
with P = 1000 N, L = 1.0 m, E = 70 GPa, I = bh³/12 = 5.208 × 10⁻⁷ m⁴ and c = h/2 = 0.025 m. The solver returned 9.1350 mm, 0.086 % below (1) (Fig. 5).
Its peak stress, 62.14 MPa, reads 29.5 % above (2) (Fig. 6). That is the right answer, not an error: the clamp concentrates stress and beam theory has no term for it, so (2) is a floor and the comparison a lower bound.
Judged that way, the run passed. Retried, it reproduced its metrics exactly.
3.2Sequence analysis
Run on the reference genome of phage λ [7], the platform’s sequence analysis returns 48,502 bp, GC 49.86 % and 69 open reading frames of at least 100 aa (Fig. 7). The longest, 1132 aa, matches the published length of the tail-fibre protein J residue for residue [8] and sits exactly on the annotated gene — an off-by-one in frame or stop-codon handling would break both. Aligning 3,370 nanopore reads with minimap2 [5] mapped 99.76 % of them and covered 99.95 % of the genome at a mean depth of 151.7×; an independent recount of the output agreed exactly.
3.3Inspecting the result
A solver writes its whole field — 54 MB in run cd6f54b4 — far more than a browser should load to show a surface. The platform extracts the outer surface, 19,716 triangles on 9,860 nodes, and sends 0.34 MB (Fig. 8). The extrema the viewer reports match the solver’s field exactly, so the picture is the result rather than an approximation of it.
| Capability | Measured | Checked against | Copy row |
|---|---|---|---|
| Finite-element analysis | 9.1350 mm tip deflection · 146,375 nodes · 103 s | Euler–Bernoulli closed form [1] | |
| Verification against theory | per-quantity verdict across five analytical cases | Roark’s formulae [1] | |
| Sequence analysis | 48,502 bp · GC 49.86 % · longest ORF 1132 aa | NC_001416.1 [7] · published length of gene J [8] | |
| Read alignment | 99.76 % mapped · 99.95 % covered · 151.7× depth | independent recount of the same output | |
| Result visualisation | 54 MB solver field reduced to a 0.34 MB surface | solver field extrema, matched exactly |
4Scope
Five workspaces share one execution path. Their depth differs, and the product says which: a workspace whose checks are not built is labelled as such rather than shown with a working-looking control.
Sojist is an analysis and decision-support layer. It never commands flight, actuation or any other safety-critical system; a qualified person makes the final call.
Each workspace in detail →| Workspace | What it does | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Engineering | Cloud FEA, theory checks, result checks, 3-D field inspection | verified |
| Physics | Five closed-form cases with references | verified |
| Biology | Genome statistics, ORFs, read alignment | verified |
| Science | Publication metadata resolved by DOI | verified |
| Aerospace | Rocket flights and campaigns on Sojist's own solver; review decisions | flights: closed-form checks; reviews: review only |
5Availability
Access is currently closed while Sojist works directly with early partners. Plans, quotas and prices are listed on the pricing page. Correspondence to Emirhan Cabuk, founder and technical lead — contact@sojist.com.
References
- Young, W. C. & Budynas, R. G. Roark’s Formulas for Stress and Strain, 7th edn. McGraw-Hill (2002).
- ASME V&V 40-2018. Assessing Credibility of Computational Modeling through Verification and Validation: Application to Medical Devices.
- Dhondt, G. The Finite Element Method for Three-Dimensional Thermomechanical Applications. Wiley (2004).
- Geuzaine, C. & Remacle, J.-F. Gmsh: a 3-D finite element mesh generator with built-in pre- and post-processing facilities. Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 79, 1309–1331 (2009).
- Li, H. Minimap2: pairwise alignment for nucleotide sequences. Bioinformatics 34, 3094–3100 (2018).
- Timoshenko, S. P. On the correction for shear of the differential equation for transverse vibrations of prismatic bars. Philos. Mag. 41, 744–746 (1921).
- NCBI Reference Sequence NC_001416.1, Enterobacteria phage lambda, complete genome.
- Wang, J., Hofnung, M. & Charbit, A. The C-terminal portion of the tail fiber protein of bacteriophage lambda is responsible for binding to LamB, its receptor at the surface of Escherichia coli K-12. J. Bacteriol. 182, 508–512 (2000).